Defining impact investing – evidence, measurement and positive outcomes

Allianz Global Investors (AllianzGI) has launched a whitepaper on defining impact and its application within private market investments.

Key highlights

  • AllianzGI has its own perspective on negative impact pathways, which can go beyond the EU SFDR definitions of Principal Adverse Indicators (PAI).
  • Within climate change, AllianzGI broadens out the concept to include “planetary boundaries”.
  • The Impact Measurement Management Team focuses on aspects throughout the lifecycle of potential and actual investments, working with portfolio managers to design, scope and carry out due diligence on impact themes, areas of focus and individual investments.
  • AllianzGI aims to apply a consistent impact approach across developed and emerging markets.

While the growth of impact investing has accelerated, definitions and approaches vary widely. Allianz Global Investors (AllianzGI) has a clear definition for impact, as discussed in their White Paper published this summer: Investing for meaningful impact in private markets.

The approach is to seek measurable evidence of companies’ positive impact on environmental and social goals, and to this end companies are grouped into three categories.

The top group are “Significant Positive Impact”, where goods and services core to their business models are solving key environmental and social challenges, often reaching underserved populations and markets, (and avoiding unintended negatives).

The second group, Positive Benefits, still need to avoid negative outcomes, and produce a good impact, but it may not for instance be reaching underserved populations. They need to raise their game to earn a meaningful place in AllianzGI Impact portfolios and the third group, Sustainability Improvers, have even more work to do to become investible for Impact portfolios (and rather, would likely sit within broader sustainability strategies).


Enterprise and Investor level impact

Enterprise-level impact is measured through the AllianzGI framework, a proprietary set of criteria, which is aligned with industry standards such as the Impact Management Project’s five dimensions of impact and the Global Impact Investing Network’s IRIS+ metrics. Key metrics could include tonnes of C02 avoided, underserved customers reached, or income gain to customers.

Alongside enterprise or company level impact, AllianzGI also seeks to identify investor contribution, through financial investment in underserved geographies/entrepreneurs and/or active engagement- to enhance impact generation.


Handprints and Footprints

“We really focus on the company’s handprint, in terms of its positive contribution to environmental and social outcomes, as assessed by our impact framework,” says Nadia Nikolova, Sustainable Private Credit AllianzGI.

The “handprint” measures if revenues of the core business model are aligned to products and services generating positive outcomes. One example could be energy efficiency solutions for buildings, where percentage of revenues coming from this service would be measured. “Companies with a good handprint are very intentional and mission-driven. In addition, they typically seek  to maintain a good reputation on footprint measures such as emissions,” says Diane Mak Head of Impact Measurement and Management.

The firm also looks at company footprints in terms of DNSH (Do No Significant Harm) criteria, which is backed up by measurable KPIs. Scope 1, 2 and 3 carbon emissions are the footprint, which is also being used to define impact by some funds. Some direct lending funds using one or more of ESG integration, sustainability improvement, Paris Alignment, Sustainability Linked, or climate transition indices and/or criteria call themselves “impact”, but they may not be pursuing the same goals as other impact investors.

AllianzGI also has its own perspective on negative impact pathways, which can go beyond the EU SFDR definitions of Principal Adverse Indicators (PAI). “For instance, when I was based in the US looking at educational deals, some private universities did not qualify because the students would have a lot of debt at the end of their studies, and at the same time the low quality of teaching at some of these institutions meant learning or employment outcomes were poor. In contrast  affordable and high-quality educational technology programmes which supplemented more “traditional” classroom learning, and which had a good evidence base for improving maths or reading outcomes,  may be good candidates for impact investing,” explains Mak.


Key sector focus areas

Within climate change, AllianzGI broadens out the concept to include “planetary boundaries”, which covers biodiversity, where there is a huge urgency to find plastic replacement alternatives, as well as sustainable agriculture and green fertilisers that do not leach toxic chemicals.

Examples of possible focus areas could include alternative education pathways to a college degree, which can narrow the skills gap, as well as digitization of healthcare to let practitioners spend more time with patients and prevent “double dosing”.


Impact Due Diligence and Investment Committee

Mak and her team focus on impact aspects throughout the lifecycle of potential and actual investments, working with portfolio managers to design, scope and carry out due diligence on impact themes, areas of focus and individual investments. They are scored for potential positive impact, based on meaningful and relevant KPIs, which can be monitored and managed.

Mak and her team provide deal input as part of pre-screening based on either overt red flags or simply a positive handprint that is not significant enough. In these cases, the idea does not proceed to in depth due diligence. Mak is also a member of the investment committee for deals that progress.


Engagement, deteriorating performance and remedial action

Mak finds impact pathways, such as handprint, and commercial performance, are very closely correlated, but companies need to be closely monitored because their business models can change. If a business is not generating enough positive impact and companies are falling behind on KPIs (or even generating negative outcomes) engagement can be an option. Early detection signs lead to engagement with the company and private equity sponsors.

“Red flags on a DNSH threshold require specific intentional engagement with a company to understand what has happened, and what mitigation actions can be taken over what period to avoid a recurrence,” says Mak.

AllianzGI is generally the sole or majority lender, and thus has a controlling creditor position, which can give it a high degree of influence (even if it does not have as much power as an equity shareholder).


Company size focus

The average direct lending fund has increased in size over the past 10 years, which has shifted the focus to mid to large companies. There are fewer direct lending strategies focused on lower mid-market companies as AllianzGI is.


Emerging and Developed Markets (EM and DM)

AllianzGI aims to apply a consistent impact approach across developed and emerging markets, seeking to pursue the same SDGs, but there are practical reasons for differences in the impact process: “in practice, data limitations in EM mean that we work more closely with DFI partners and rely on their assessments. In developed markets our own analysis plays a larger role, “ points out Mak.

“The Emerging markets context creates an additional layer of credit / political / currency and other risk which require assessment. In these markets, we tend to partner with Development Finance Institutions and use blended finance to reduce said risks to our investors.,” says Nikolova. Providing capital where it is scarce, in underbanked countries, is one example of impact in itself.

In DM most of AllianzGI’s impact investing is in Europe, but it can extend to other OECD countries. , Allianz GI does not expect impact strategies to sacrifice investment returns. Competitive returns are sought.

  • Disclaimer
    This is a marketing communication. For investment professionals only. Investing involves risk. The value of an investment and the income from it may fall as well as rise and investors might not get back the full amount invested. Past performance does not predict future returns.

    AdMaster: 3148775

Explore Insights

Allianz Working Capital fund is diversified and adapts to geopolitics with minimal tariff impact. Trade finance remains attractive despite global growth concerns

Read More

A shift is underway in markets. Global investors are eyeing opportunities in Europe amid improved prospects for the region and growing uncertainty in the US. As the world turns on its head, our latest House View points a way through the complexity.

Read More

Embracing Disruption

In our previous note, we outlined the reasons why we believe India warrants a premium valuation among global equity markets. Since then, India’s relative valuations have fallen to an all-time low. Given this sharp pullback, we want to articulate why we see a potentially compelling entry point for investors.

Read More

Allianz Global Investors

You are now leaving the Allianz Global Investors’ website and being redirected to

Welcome to the Allianz Global Investors website dedicated to the United Kingdom

Select Role
  • Adviser & Wealth Manager
  • Individual Investor
  • Institutional Investor
  • You have connected to this site as a “Professional” as defined by MiFID.  To continue, you must have the experience and knowledge required in investment management, particularly regarding the risks involved in accessing this site.

    If you are not a “Professional” client, we invite you to leave this page and reconnect on the “Individuals” page from the Allianz Global Investors website.

    US persons: The information shown on this site is not intended for US citizens, US nationals, or to those US persons such as defined by “Regulation S” of the Securities and Exchange Commission under the Security Act of 1933.

    This site is only intended to provide information on Allianz Global Investors and the products authorised for marketing in the UK.  The information presented on this site does not constitute an offer to sell or subscribe to a financial instrument.

    The views and opinions expressed herein, which are subject to change without notice, are those of the issuer companies at the time of publication. Your access is subject to the UK regulation and to the legal terms and general conditions of access to this site.

    In choosing to access our site, you acknowledge that you understand and accept these conditions.  We advise, for your best interest, to read these conditions carefully.

    Please read the following page carefully before proceeding as it contains important information concerning your use of the website and explains certain legal and regulatory restrictions applicable to any investment in Allianz Global Investors investment products. By pressing ‘Accept’ you agree that you have read and understood the following information.

    The material on this site is directed only at persons in the UK and does not constitute an offer or invitation to buy or sell the funds to persons in any jurisdiction other than the UK.

    Allianz Global Investors (AllianzGI) has taken reasonable care to ensure the accuracy of information available through the site. However, the information may be amended at any time by AllianzGI without notice. As far as it is permitted under the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000, AllianzGI does not accept liability for any loss, direct or indirect, owing to reliance on any information contained herein.

    Opinions expressed whether in general or both on the performance of individual funds and in a wider economic context represent the views of the contributor at the time of preparation. They are subject to change and should not be interpreted as investment advice which AllianzGI is not authorised to give.

    This site may provide links to third party websites over which AllianzGI has no control. These links are provided for your convenience and AllianzGI accepts no responsibility for the content of such websites.

    For your security we may record or randomly monitor all telephone calls.

    A word of warning
    Past performance does not predict future returns. The value of investments and the income from them can go down as well as up and an investor may not get back the amount invested. 

    Exchange rate fluctuations may vary causing the value of overseas investments to go down or up. For your own security any calls may be recorded and randomly monitored.

    For information on any specific risks associated with our funds and products please see our Key Investor Information Documents (KIIDs) and Supplementary Information Documents (SIDs).

    The use of this website is subject to English Law and any dispute will fall under the jurisdiction of the English courts.

    Regulation and Status Disclosure
    Allianz Global Investors represents products and services of Allianz Global Investors UK Limited, www.allianzglobalinvestors.co.uk. Allianz Global Investors UK Limited is an investment company, incorporated in the United Kingdom, with its registered office at 199 Bishopsgate, London, EC2M 3TY. 

    Allianz Global Investors UK Limited, company number 11516839, is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority. Details about the extent of our regulation are available from us on request and on the Financial Conduct Authority’s website (www.fca.org.uk). The duplication, publication, or transmission of the contents, irrespective of the form, is not permitted; except for the case of explicit permission by Allianz Global Investors UK Limited.

    Throughout the website Allianz Global Investors UK Limited may sometimes be referred to as Allianz Global Investors or AllianzGI.

    Copyright
    Copyright in this website is owned by Allianz Global Investors UK Limited. The copyrights of third parties are reserved.

    You may download or print a hard copy of individual pages and/or sections of the website, provided that you do not remove any copyright or other proprietary notices. Any downloading or other copying from the website will not transfer title to any software or material to you.

    You may not reproduce (in whole or part), transmit (by electronic means or otherwise), modify, link or use for any public or commercial purpose the website without the prior permission of Allianz Global Investors.

    Cookies
    Allianz Global Investors UK Limited uses session cookies for the purpose of saving data relating to the management of a user session in the memory of the web browser on the user’s computer. By cookie it is meant the small text file that is stored on the hard disk of a computer by the web browser on the said computer. Such file contains information sent by the web server of the Website that a user has visited. The information derived from session cookies enables Allianz Global Investors UK Limited to identify which areas of the Website are seemingly of more interest to users so that it can improve the Website and the information provided to users. The data which is stored via session cookies does not include any private information regarding the user, and is erased as soon as the browser is shut down. It is to be noted that most web browsers are set up in such a way that they automatically accept cookies. Users can, however, amend the configuration of the web browser on their computers so that they are systematically notified of any instance where the Websites that they are about to visit contain cookies.

Please check the checkbox to accept the terms and conditions.